Fads Versus Facts: Busting Myths about Nutrition and Exercise
Setup
For decades, diet and exercise fads have promised to shrink waistlines, build muscle, detoxify, and so on. But evidence is mounting that there’s no one diet or routine that works for everyone. Researchers are experimenting with AI to determine personalized nutrition algorithms based on an individual’s health, lifestyle, physiology, and immune system. Christie Aschwanden, author of "Good to Go," sits down with Eric Topol, executive vice president of Scripps Research, and Corby Kummer, executive director of the Food and Society program at the Aspen Institute, to debunk long-standing myths surrounding diet and exercise recovery. Are you ready to rethink your regimen?
- 2019 Festival
- Health
- Society
- Technology
Athletes (and everyone): prioritize sleep!
Journalist Christie Aschwanden wrote a book about how athletes should recover from training so that they can perform at their best. “Spoiler alert,” she told an audience at Aspen Ideas. “The number one thing athletes can do for recovery is sleep.” Aschwanden, a former cycling champion and elite nordic skier, says nothing else comes close to the power of a good night’s rest.
Good sleep isn’t just for athletes, Aschwanden says, it’s important for any kind of performance including political debates. She recalls a piece in The New York Times that explains how much sleep the democratic presidential candidates receive. “So many of them were saying they got four or five hours of sleep, which is just terrible...It shows a lack of priorities.”
Stretching isn’t what it’s cracked up to be
Sure, stretching feels good and it’s a nice ritual before or after exercise but science shows it doesn’t reduce the risk of injury. In fact, research on runners shows stretching before an athletic event may reduce performance slightly, says Christie Aschwanden. “So many people are stretching in hopes that they will be less sore or reduce their chance of injury and it turns out that that doesn’t hold up.” Stretching will help your flexibility, she says. “So if you are stretching to be able to touch your toes better, continue to do so.”
Who Knew?
The Guisinger “Farmacy” is using food as medicine
The doctors at Guisinger Medical Center in Danville, Pennsylvania are seeing their patients become healthier thanks to food. Eric Topol, professor of molecular medicine, says the hospital created a program to address high levels of food insecurity in its region. Food insecurity — a lack of nutritious food — can lead to diabetes and obesity. Guisinger’s “Fresh Food Farmacy” doles out prescriptions for healthy, diabetes-appropriate food to patients with type 2 diabetes. “[The patients] had a remarkable improvement of glucose regulation and a big reduction in their need for emergency room visits and hospitalizations...You wonder why we don’t do this more,” says Topol.
Science is often wrong on the way to being right
In the summer of 2000, President Clinton announced that the Human Genome Project had assembled a working draft of the sequence of the human genome. Eric Topol says after that, the expectations for the genome to improve health were high, but “we didn’t understand how important the gut microbiome was.” Now, new findings are emerging about how the microbiome impacts drug effectiveness, for example. Christie Aschwanden, though, urges caution.
This exchange has been lightly edited for clarity
-
Christie Aschwanden: I don’t think the public always has a good understanding of how science works and how it progresses. Science is a process of uncertainty reduction. Too often, the public has been given this view that science is a magic wand that turns everything it touches into truth, but it turns out that science is often wrong on the way to being right ...The microbiome stuff is so exciting and we know it’s very important. But, I think it’s important to understand that these are early days …[What we] see again and again are times when there’s one small study that had some really enticing and interesting finding and everyone jumps on the bandwagon — everyone’s doing this thing, taking this drug, or eating this food. Then, more studies come out and it turns out we had things completely wrong.
-
Eric Topol: Coffee and everything that we take in — there are studies that show that it’s either good or bad. In my book ("Deep Medicine"), I include a graphic that shows hundreds of studies [around one product] that show it will either kill you or make you healthier. The thing is, there may be some truth to that because we are all so individualized in our response. So, for some people a Keto diet may be really good for them. The excitement I have, and I agree about the science and the need for replication and uncertainty, is that we’re making some headway here. No one had expected that the gut microbiome was going to be such a big driver in our nutritional response.
Learn More
Additional Information
Resources
Explore More
Health
Young people in America are struggling. The causes are varied and may not be entirely clear, but the results are unfortunately unmistakable. Many of our youth feel lonely, iso...
New technologies have always led to changes in society, though not always as quickly or drastically as people feared. Could artificial intelligence be different? Instead of le...
In America, millions of people struggle with mental health including depression, anxiety, and more — all further exacerbated by living through a pandemic. The National Allianc...
Our attitudes, habits, pleasures, and responsibilities shift across the generations, influencing the health challenges we face and how we respond to them. Expectations about h...
Friends, partners, children, families, coworkers — these connections profoundly shape our lives, and even in the best of times, navigating them takes real work. It also means...
New York Times columnist and bestselling author David Brooks is known for bringing his thoughtful reflections on politics and culture, but at this year’s Aspen Ideas Festival,...
Jump in by watching our 15 most popular talks of all time. From black holes to jazz and civil rights to psychology hacks, we've collected the talks that remain audience favori...
Finding the national and global headlines understandably bleak lately? Whether you need mental distraction or stimulation, engross yourself in compelling topics and get a gli...
The United States spends $4.3 trillion—almost one fifth of the nation’s GDP—on health care. As the scale of the medical enterprise expands, venture capitalists are pursuing th...
Today's kids are coming of age against a backdrop of political, social, technological and economic upheaval. While these circumstances are shaping a precocious generation that...
Hope seems like a simple concept, but the feeling can be difficult to hold onto. And when times are difficult and chaos swirls around us, it’s more important than ever. How do...
Advocates, healthcare providers, legislators, researchers, and venture capitalists are bringing the unique health needs of women to light – from vigorous policy debates on iss...
From the debate over reproductive rights to the epidemic of gun violence to the youth mental health crisis, this year's Aspen Ideas: Health sessions tackled many of today's mo...
The recognition that all things are connected is at once a scientific principle and a philosophical touchstone. Humans, animals, and the environment are intertwined in complex...
Everywhere you look, there’s a headline about the power of artificial intelligence and how it will impact our lives in ways we have not yet imagined. From advancing medicine t...
Ethical dilemmas, stakeholder pressure, building trust — leading organizations requires wisdom and stamina from the top. Who wouldn’t want some advice?
What makes us happy — really? How can we raise resilient and empathetic children? What does it mean to be truly connected in our increasingly digital world? Can we re-instill...
Where will artificial intelligence be in five years, or 10 or 20? What happens if the technology is regulated? And if it isn’t? How will it shape the world and the way we live...
Whether they publicly tout it or not, U.S. technology companies play a powerful role in politics, cultural issues and the way we live. Founder and investor Peter Thiel is one...
Our need for human connection is profound and deep. Yet, today, one in two adults are living with measurable levels of loneliness – and the numbers are even higher among young...